Practice Area

Enforcement and Insolvency Law Attorney · Ataşehir, Istanbul

Legal representation in enforcement proceedings with and without a judgment, proceedings based on negotiable instruments, attachment, auctions, concordat and bankruptcy.

What Is Enforcement and Insolvency Law?

Enforcement and insolvency law is the branch of law governing how a creditor obtains a monetary or security claim through the State without the debtor's consent. Its main source is the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law (İİK) No. 2004. Under this law the creditor's main options are enforcement without a judgment, enforcement based on a judgment, enforcement specific to negotiable instruments and enforcement by realisation of a pledge.

Bankruptcy law, by contrast, is a collective enforcement procedure in which all of the debtor's assets are liquidated and distributed among the creditors. For debtors in financial difficulty, the institution of concordat offers a way to avoid bankruptcy. For both creditors and debtors, enforcement proceedings are a technical area requiring careful follow-up of short time limits.

Our Enforcement and Insolvency Law Services

At Şahin Hukuk Bürosu we provide legal support to our clients in various areas of enforcement and insolvency law:

Enforcement Without a Judgment

Collection of monetary and security claims, issuing payment orders, actions to set aside objections and requests to lift objections.

Enforcement Based on a Judgment

Legal support in enforcement proceedings based on court judgments and in the execution and collection of judgments.

Enforcement Based on Negotiable Instruments

Enforcement based on cheques, promissory notes and bills of exchange, objections to the debt or signature, and actions to annul such proceedings.

Attachment

Attachment of movables, real estate, bank accounts, salaries, vehicles and receivables held by third parties, and follow-up.

Actions to Set Aside Objections and Negative Declaratory Actions

Actions to set aside a debtor's objection; negative declaratory and restitution actions to prove that no debt is owed.

Auctions and Sales

Following auctions for the sale of attached assets, taking part in auctions and actions to annul auctions.

Concordat

Concordat applications for debtors, temporary and definitive moratoria, creditors' meetings and court approval of the concordat project.

Bankruptcy Proceedings and Liquidation

Bankruptcy enforcement, direct bankruptcy actions, bankruptcy estate procedures and registration and ranking of claims.

Types of Enforcement Proceedings

The Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law provides different routes from which the creditor can choose. Choosing the right route is decisive for the speed and effectiveness of the process.

Enforcement Without a Judgment

This is enforcement based solely on an alleged claim, without a court judgment. It is only available for monetary and security claims. The debtor can object to the payment order within 7 days of service; the objection suspends the proceedings. To overcome the objection, the creditor can file an action to set aside the objection (in the general courts, within 1 year) or request lifting of the objection (before the enforcement court, within 6 months).

Enforcement Based on a Judgment

This is enforcement based on a court judgment or documents having the force of a judgment. An enforcement order is served on the debtor; the right to object is very limited. It is a faster type of proceeding.

Enforcement Based on Negotiable Instruments

This is enforcement based on cheques, promissory notes and bills of exchange. It is a fast route, and the objection period is 5 days. The debtor can only object to the signature and to the debt; these objections are examined by the enforcement court. An objection to the signature does not suspend the proceedings, and neither does an objection to the debt unless the court orders otherwise.

Enforcement by Realisation of a Pledge

This route is used for claims secured by a pledge, such as a mortgage or a pledge over movables. Recourse must first be had to the pledged asset.

The Enforcement Process

The stages we follow in enforcement files at Şahin Hukuk Bürosu:

  1. Review of the Claim and Documents Reviewing contracts, invoices, instruments and other documents, and determining the nature of the claim and the enforcement route.
  2. Preparing the Enforcement Request Preparing the request at the competent enforcement office and determining the type and rate of interest, attorney fees and enforcement costs.
  3. Service of the Payment Order / Enforcement Order Service on the debtor, checking the validity of service and, if necessary, address searches.
  4. Objection or Payment Actions to set aside or lift objections if an objection is made; closing the file if payment is made.
  5. Attachment Asset searches through banks, SGK, vehicle registration, land registry and UYAP; physical and registered attachments.
  6. Sale and Collection Putting attached assets up for sale, auction, distribution of proceeds and completion of the file.

Rights of the Debtor

Debtors who are party to enforcement proceedings also have various legal options. Against erroneous or unlawful proceedings, the debtor can use the following remedies:

  • Objection to the payment order: Filed with the enforcement office within 7 days (without a judgment) or 5 days (negotiable instruments) of service. The objection suspends the proceedings.
  • Complaint: Actions of the enforcement office can be challenged before the enforcement court (İİK Art. 16). The time limit is generally 7 days.
  • Negative declaratory action: A person claiming not to owe the debt can file an action in the general courts to stop the proceedings or recover payments (İİK Art. 72).
  • Restitution action: A person who has paid although not owing the debt can file this action to recover the money paid (İİK Art. 72/3).
  • Declaration of assets: The debtor has the right and the obligation to declare their assets within the time limit.
  • Assets exempt from attachment: Under İİK Arts. 82 and 83 certain assets cannot be attached (essential household items, religious and professional books, a certain portion of the minimum wage, etc.).

Concordat: A Rescue Route for Debtors

Concordat, provided to help debtors in financial difficulty avoid bankruptcy, allows debts to be restructured or partly written off by agreement with the creditors. It is governed by İİK Art. 285 et seq.

Types of Concordat

  • Ordinary concordat: An agreement with all creditors.
  • Concordat by assignment of assets: Concordat in which the debtor assigns their assets to the creditors.
  • Concordat after bankruptcy: Concordat proposed after bankruptcy has been declared.

Process

  1. Application and Temporary Moratorium The debtor applies to the commercial court with a concordat project; the court grants a 3-month temporary moratorium (extendable by 2 months if necessary).
  2. Appointment of a Temporary Commissioner The court appoints a temporary concordat commissioner and the debtor's assets are examined.
  3. Definitive Moratorium and Creditors' Meeting A definitive moratorium of 1 year (extendable by 6 months if necessary); creditors vote on the project, which is accepted once the required majority is reached.
  4. Court Approval The court approves the concordat project and the implementation stage begins.

Our Approach

Enforcement and insolvency law has strict time limits and technical procedures for both creditors and debtors. At Şahin Hukuk Bürosu we offer:

  • Monitoring time limits: Preventing loss of rights by carefully monitoring the deadlines for objections, actions and complaints.
  • Choosing the right route: Selecting the fastest and most effective route according to the nature of the claim.
  • Asset searches: Speeding up collection through comprehensive searches of UYAP, bank, land registry, vehicle and SGK records.
  • Debtor defence: Effective use of objections, negative declaratory actions and complaints against erroneous proceedings.
  • Insight from both sides: Our experience in both creditor and debtor files allows us to anticipate all aspects of the process.

Frequently Asked Questions

Enforcement proceedings have been started against me. What should I do?

First, check whether the document served on you is a payment order or an enforcement order. A payment order is sent in enforcement without a judgment, and an objection must be filed with the enforcement office within 7 days. In enforcement based on negotiable instruments (cheques, promissory notes), the objection period is 5 days and the objection is filed with the enforcement court. If you miss the deadline, the proceedings become final and move on to attachment. If you do not actually owe the debt or the amount is different, an objection is essential. Your objection should state clearly what you are objecting to (the debt, interest, jurisdiction, signature). Because the time limits are very short, it is important to obtain legal support without delay once you receive the notice.

My salary has been attached. How much will be deducted?

Under Article 83 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law, only one quarter of an employee's salary can be attached. This limit does not apply to maintenance claims; for maintenance, the whole salary can be attached (priority is given to maintenance). Retirement pensions cannot, as a rule, be attached (Social Security Law Art. 93); however, attachment is possible with the pensioner's written consent or for maintenance claims. If there are several attachments, they are ranked in order and the one-quarter limit is still respected. The amount necessary for subsistence cannot be reduced.

Enforcement proceedings have been started although I owe nothing. What can I do?

If proceedings have been started against you although you owe nothing, there are two main routes. First route: Object to the payment order in time to suspend the proceedings; if the creditor does not then file an action to set aside the objection, the proceedings lapse. Second route: If you missed the objection deadline or were forced to pay, you can file a negative declaratory action (declaration that you do not owe the debt) or a restitution action (recovery of the money paid) under İİK Art. 72. A negative declaratory action filed before the proceedings become final may stop them, but security may be required. As the burden of proof lies with the person claiming not to owe the debt, evidence must be prepared carefully.

My bank account has been attached. Will all the money in it be taken?

When your bank account is attached, the amount in the enforcement file is blocked from the balance on the date of attachment; funds arriving later are also blocked until the amount due is reached. However, if it is the account into which your salary is paid, you have the right to object for three quarters of the salary amount (İİK Art. 83). If the account is joint, only your share can be attached. Certain amounts in your account, such as maintenance, scholarships and social benefits, are exempt from attachment, and you must object to their attachment by way of complaint to the enforcement court. In case of erroneous attachment, the 7-day complaint period must be observed.

Can duplicate proceedings (two files for the same debt) be brought?

Starting more than one enforcement proceeding against the same debtor for the same claim constitutes duplicate enforcement and is unlawful. On learning of it, the debtor can object by way of complaint to the enforcement court. Duplicate enforcement may take the form of the same creditor opening two separate files based on the same document, starting both enforcement without and with a judgment, or opening different files by presenting the claim as assigned to several persons. If the enforcement court finds duplicate enforcement upon complaint, it annuls the second proceeding. Such fraudulent methods may also constitute enforcement and bankruptcy offences (İİK Art. 331 et seq.) and give rise to criminal liability.

Need Legal Support in Enforcement and Insolvency?

Tell us about your situation and get initial information from our attorneys.