Practice Area

Arbitration and Mediation Attorney · Ataşehir

Legal representation and advice in national and international arbitration and in mandatory and voluntary mediation.

What Are Arbitration and Mediation?

Arbitration and mediation are Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) methods that allow disputes to be resolved faster and more flexibly, without going to court or in parallel with court proceedings. In Turkish law both methods have been strengthened by legislation and have become widely used, particularly in commercial disputes.

Their main sources are the International Arbitration Law No. 4686, the arbitration provisions (Arts. 407-444) of the Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100, the Law on Mediation in Civil Disputes No. 6325, the mandatory mediation provisions of the Labour Courts Law No. 7036 and the relevant provisions of the Consumer Protection Law No. 6502.

The key difference between the two is this: arbitration is an adjudicative method based on a binding decision rendered by arbitrators chosen by the parties. Mediation, on the other hand, is a process in which the parties try to reach a solution of their own will with the help of a neutral facilitator who helps them agree.

Our Arbitration and Mediation Services

At Şahin Hukuk Bürosu we provide a range of services to our clients in arbitration and mediation:

Domestic Arbitration

Acting as party counsel in domestic arbitration under Code of Civil Procedure Arts. 407-444, representation before the arbitral tribunal and case management.

International Arbitration

Representation and advice under Law No. 4686 and before international arbitral institutions (ICC, ISTAC, LCIA, UNCITRAL).

Arbitration Clauses and Contract Review

Drafting arbitration clauses in commercial contracts and reviewing arbitration provisions in existing contracts.

Setting Aside and Enforcement of Awards

Actions to set aside arbitral awards and the recognition and enforcement of foreign arbitral awards in Türkiye.

Mandatory Mediation

Representation in mandatory mediation, which is a precondition for filing suit in employment, commercial and consumer disputes.

Voluntary Mediation

Strategic advice and negotiation support in mediation initiated by the parties' own choice.

Mediation Settlement Agreement

Drafting the settlement agreements signed at the end of mediation and obtaining enforceability annotations.

Investment Arbitration (BIT/ICSID)

Advice in investor-state disputes based on bilateral investment treaties.

Arbitration: A Binding Alternative to Litigation

Arbitration is a method in which the parties choose to resolve their dispute through an arbitrator or arbitral tribunal of their own choosing instead of the state courts. Once final, an arbitral award is enforceable like a court judgment.

Advantages of Arbitration

  • Speed: It usually concludes faster than state court proceedings.
  • Expertise: Arbitrators with knowledge of the subject can be chosen (engineering, finance, construction, etc.).
  • Confidentiality: As a rule, the proceedings and the award are private; commercially sensitive information is protected.
  • International enforceability: Under the 1958 New York Convention, foreign arbitral awards are recognised in more than 160 countries.
  • Flexible procedure: The parties can determine the language, seat and rules of the proceedings.

Limits of Arbitration

  • Arbitrability: Not all disputes can be arbitrated. Disputes concerning divorce, parentage and rights in rem over immovable property are excluded from arbitration (Code of Civil Procedure Art. 408).
  • Arbitration agreement requirement: The parties must have agreed in writing to arbitrate.
  • Cost: Arbitrators' fees and institutional costs can be high, especially in international arbitration.
  • Limited review: Remedies against an arbitral award are limited (only an action to set aside, on narrow grounds).

Leading Arbitral Institutions

  • ISTAC: Istanbul Arbitration Centre — the most important institutional arbitration centre based in Türkiye.
  • ITOTAM: Istanbul Chamber of Commerce Arbitration and Mediation Centre.
  • ICC: International Chamber of Commerce (Paris) — the most widely used arbitral institution worldwide.
  • LCIA: London Court of International Arbitration.
  • UNCITRAL: United Nations Commission on International Trade Law model — for ad hoc arbitration.
  • ICSID: For investment disputes (at the World Bank).

The Arbitration Process

The main stages of arbitral proceedings:

  1. Request for Arbitration and Notification The claimant notifies the request for arbitration to the other party and, if one has been chosen, to the arbitral institution.
  2. Appointment of Arbitrators Appointment of a sole arbitrator or a three-member tribunal; the parties nominate arbitrators and the tribunal is constituted.
  3. First Meeting and Procedural Order The arbitrators convene the parties and determine the procedure (terms of reference, procedural rules).
  4. Written Submissions and Evidence Statements of defence and reply, document production, witness statements and expert reports.
  5. Oral Hearing Hearing of the parties and witnesses, and argument before the tribunal.
  6. Arbitral Award The reasoned award is drafted and notified to the parties. The award must be rendered within the time limits laid down by law.

Mediation: A Solution by the Parties' Own Will

Mediation is a negotiation process conducted with the assistance of a neutral and independent third party (the mediator) who helps the parties shape their own agreement. The mediator does not decide; they help the parties find their own solution.

Core Principles of Mediation

  • Voluntariness: The parties can withdraw at any stage; however, in mandatory mediation there is an obligation to attend the first meeting.
  • Equality: Equal treatment of the parties and an equal right to be heard.
  • Confidentiality: Information and offers shared during mediation are confidential and cannot be used as evidence in court if no agreement is reached.
  • Impartiality and independence: The mediator stands at an equal distance from both parties.

Areas of Mandatory Mediation

In Turkish law, mediation is a precondition for filing suit in certain disputes; if a case is filed without first applying to a mediator, it is dismissed on procedural grounds.

  • Employment Disputes: Law No. 7036 Art. 3 — severance and notice pay, overtime, annual leave, reinstatement and other employee claims.
  • Commercial Disputes: Turkish Commercial Code Art. 5/A — for receivables and compensation claims for the payment of a sum of money.
  • Consumer Disputes: Law No. 6502 Art. 73/A — for consumer cases above the monetary limit of the consumer arbitration committees.
  • Certain Disputes Arising from Leases: The mediation requirement for lease disputes introduced by the 2023 amendments.

Mediation Settlement Agreement

If the parties reach an agreement at the end of the process, the settlement agreement prepared by the mediator is signed by the parties and the mediator. If signed by the parties, their attorneys and the mediator, the document counts as a document equivalent to a court judgment and can be enforced directly (Mediation Law Art. 18/4). Otherwise, an enforceability annotation must be obtained from the civil court of peace.

The Mediation Process

The stages we follow in mediation files at Şahin Hukuk Bürosu:

  1. Strategy and Preparation Determining the client's position, demands and flexibility, and developing a negotiation strategy.
  2. Documents and Calculations Calculating claims, analysing the contract and bringing the supporting documents to the table.
  3. Selection/Appointment of the Mediator If the parties agree, they choose their own mediator; otherwise one is appointed from the court list.
  4. First Meeting and Negotiation Sharing the parties' positions, joint and separate sessions, and evaluating options.
  5. Agreement or No Agreement If agreement is reached, the document is prepared and signed; if not, the final minutes are taken and the case proceeds to court.
  6. Implementing the Agreement Monitoring the terms of the agreement, receiving payment or, if necessary, initiating enforcement proceedings.

Key Differences between Arbitration and Mediation

  • Decision-maker: In arbitration the tribunal decides; in mediation the parties make their own agreement.
  • Binding effect: An arbitral award is directly binding; a mediation agreement becomes binding only when signed by the parties.
  • Process: Arbitration is formal adjudication; mediation is informal negotiation.
  • Cost: Arbitration is generally more expensive than mediation.
  • Duration: Mediation is usually completed within weeks; arbitration can take months or years.
  • Subject-matter limits: For both methods, the matters suitable for arbitration/mediation are determined by law.

Our Approach

Arbitration and mediation require both strategic thinking and effective negotiation skills. At Şahin Hukuk Bürosu we offer:

  • Negotiation-focused approach: We always assess the possibilities of settlement before litigation; this benefits the client in terms of both time and cost.
  • Foresight at the contract stage: A well-drafted arbitration clause in commercial contracts ensures that future disputes can be resolved effectively.
  • International experience: Coordinated support with our partner firm in Cologne in arbitration arising from Turkish-German commercial relations.
  • Thorough preparation: We come to the mediation table with complete documents, accurate calculations and clear arguments.
  • Transparent assessment: Giving the client realistic information about the advantages and disadvantages of ADR methods.

Frequently Asked Questions

Our contract has an arbitration clause. Can I go to court?

In a dispute arising from a contract containing an arbitration clause, if one party files suit directly in the state courts, the other party has the right to raise an arbitration objection (Code of Civil Procedure Art. 413). This objection must be raised when submitting the statement of defence; otherwise it is deemed tacitly waived and the court continues the proceedings. If the objection is upheld, the court dismisses the case on procedural grounds and the dispute must be resolved by arbitration. For an arbitration clause to be valid, it must be in writing, the dispute must be arbitrable and the clause must be clear. If the clause is invalid or inoperable (e.g. a clause that does not identify the institution or contains contradictory provisions), it may be possible to go to court.

Is mediation mandatory, and what happens if I don't attend?

In Turkish law, mediation is a precondition for filing suit in certain disputes; a case filed without first applying to a mediator is dismissed on procedural grounds. Areas of mandatory mediation: employee-employer claims and reinstatement cases (Law No. 7036 Art. 3), commercial monetary claims (Turkish Commercial Code Art. 5/A), consumer disputes (Law No. 6502 Art. 73/A) and, under recent legislation, certain lease disputes. In these cases, the final minutes showing that a mediator was approached must be attached to the statement of claim. In mandatory mediation, if a party fails to attend the first meeting without a valid excuse, that party is held liable for all of the litigation costs even if it is partly or wholly successful in the case, and no attorney's fee is awarded in its favour. The parties must attend the first meeting, but there is no obligation to reach an agreement — they can withdraw from the process at any stage.

Can I challenge an arbitral award?

Remedies against an arbitral award are very limited; only an action to set aside can be brought, and there is no appeal on the merits. Under Code of Civil Procedure Art. 439, the grounds for setting aside are limited and are: invalidity of the arbitration agreement, irregular appointment of the arbitrators, expiry of the arbitration period, the arbitrators exceeding their authority, failure to treat the parties equally, restriction of the right to be heard, non-arbitrability and violation of public policy. Time limit: For domestic arbitration, the action to set aside is filed with the regional court of appeal within 1 month of notification of the award to the parties. For foreign arbitral awards, a recognition and enforcement action is required under the Private International Law Act No. 5718 and the New York Convention; the grounds for refusal are also limited (New York Convention Art. V). Unless set aside, an arbitral award is enforceable.

What is the legal force of a mediation agreement?

If the parties reach an agreement at the end of mediation, the mediator prepares a settlement agreement. Its legal force depends on who signed it. Document equivalent to a court judgment (Mediation Law Art. 18/4): If the settlement agreement is signed by the parties, their attorneys and the mediator, it can be enforced directly; no court approval is required. Enforceability annotation: If the parties or their attorneys have not signed it, an enforceability annotation must be obtained from the civil court of peace. Contractual nature: An agreement without an annotation and not signed by attorneys is a binding contract between the parties; if one party fails to perform its obligations, the other can bring a claim. In practice, an enforceable settlement agreement signed with attorneys offers the strongest protection — which is why it is important to attend mediation with an attorney and ensure the agreement is drafted correctly.

Can I enforce a foreign arbitral award in Türkiye?

Türkiye is a party to the 1958 New York Convention on the recognition and enforcement of foreign arbitral awards. Awards rendered in more than 160 countries can therefore be recognised and enforced in Türkiye under certain conditions. The process: under the New York Convention and Arts. 60-63 of the Private International Law Act No. 5718, a recognition and enforcement action is filed with the commercial court of first instance. The main grounds on which recognition and enforcement may be refused are: invalidity of the arbitration agreement, violation of the right to be heard, the award exceeding the scope of the submission, irregularity of the arbitral procedure, the award not being binding or having been set aside, and the award being contrary to public policy. With the enforcement judgment obtained, the foreign award can be enforced in Türkiye like a Turkish court judgment. The process is usually completed within one to two years.

Need Legal Support in Arbitration or Mediation?

Tell us about your dispute and let us assess the most suitable way to resolve it together.