What Is Administrative Law?
Administrative law is the branch of public law that governs the organisation and functioning of the public administration and its relations with individuals. Its main sources are the Constitution, the Administrative Procedure Law (İYUK) No. 2577, the Civil Servants Law No. 657, the Public Financial Management and Control Law No. 5018, the Expropriation Law No. 2942, the Public Procurement Laws Nos. 4734-4735 and the Misdemeanours Law No. 5326.
Administrative law covers many matters, including annulment actions against administrative acts, full remedy actions for compensation of damage caused by the administration, challenges to administrative fines, civil service disputes, expropriation and procurement challenges. The time limit for filing actions against administrative acts is, as a rule, 60 days and is preclusive; a prompt assessment and case preparation are therefore essential.
Our Administrative Law Services
At Şahin Hukuk Bürosu we provide advice and litigation services to our clients in various areas of administrative law:
Annulment Actions
Filing and pursuing annulment actions before the administrative court on the ground that an administrative act is unlawful (İYUK Art. 2/a).
Full Remedy Actions
Actions for pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages for harm caused by an act or action of the administration (İYUK Art. 2/b).
Challenging Administrative Fines
Challenging traffic, environmental and other non-tax administrative fines before the criminal judgeship of peace or the administrative court.
Civil Service Law and Disciplinary Proceedings
Disciplinary penalties, appointments and transfers, suspension and retirement disputes under Law No. 657.
Expropriation Cases
Determination of expropriation compensation, de facto seizure without expropriation, urgent expropriation and annulment actions.
Procurement Disputes
Challenges to tender specifications, applications to the Public Procurement Authority (KİK) and annulment actions under Public Procurement Law No. 4734.
Zoning and Zoning Sanctions
Annulment of zoning plans, permit procedures, demolition orders, zoning fines and building registration certificate procedures.
Foreigners and Citizenship Law
Citizenship applications, cancellation of residence permits, appeals against deportation orders and administrative detention.
The Administrative Court System and Competent Courts
In Türkiye, administrative jurisdiction is organised as a system separate from ordinary jurisdiction. The main structure is as follows:
Administrative Courts and Tax Courts
These act as courts of first instance. Administrative courts have general jurisdiction in administrative matters, while specialised tax courts deal with tax disputes. Proceedings are, as a rule, conducted on the file; however, a hearing may be held where necessary.
Regional Administrative Courts (Appeal)
Decisions of administrative and tax courts can be appealed. Regional Administrative Courts review the file on both procedure and merits.
Council of State (Danıştay)
Türkiye's highest administrative court. It acts both as the court of cassation and, in certain matters, as a court of first instance (decisions of the Council of Ministers, regulatory acts affecting several districts, etc.).
The Difference Between Administrative Acts and Administrative Actions
In administrative law, the distinction between an administrative act and an administrative action is critical in determining the type of action.
Administrative Act
Unilateral decisions of the administration, based on a declaration of will, that produce legal effects. Appointment decisions, granting or revoking permits, administrative fines, zoning plans and expropriation decisions are examples. As a rule, an annulment action is filed against an administrative act.
Administrative Action
The physical conduct of the administration and material events. A patient being wrongly operated on, a pupil injured in an accident at a state school or a public official causing a traffic accident are examples. A full remedy action is filed for damage suffered as a result of an administrative action.
Annulment Action: Conditions and Process
An annulment action is filed to render an unlawful administrative act void. Certain conditions must be met to file this action, defined in İYUK Art. 2:
- Final and enforceable act: The act in question must produce legal effects.
- Infringement of interest: The claimant's direct, personal, current and legitimate interest must be affected by the act.
- Time limit: As a general rule, 60 days from notification or knowledge of the act. In tax cases the time limit is 30 days.
- Competent court: As a rule, the administrative court of the place where the authority issuing the act is located.
Grounds for Annulment
An administrative act is subject to annulment if one of the following grounds exists (İYUK Art. 2/1-a):
- Competence: The authority issuing the act was not competent (ratione materiae, ratione loci, ratione temporis).
- Form: The formal requirements prescribed by law were not met (written form, statement of reasons, opinion of an advisory body, etc.).
- Cause: The factual or legal grounds on which the act is based are incorrect.
- Subject matter: The legal effect of the act is contrary to law.
- Purpose: The act was carried out for personal or other purposes rather than the public interest (misuse of power).
Full Remedy Action: The Compensation Mechanism
A person harmed by an act or action of the administration claims compensation for pecuniary and non-pecuniary damage through a full remedy action. The basic principles:
- Service fault: The administration failing to perform its duty, performing it badly or performing it late.
- Strict liability: In some cases the administration may be liable for damage even without fault (social risk, hazardous activities, etc.).
- Causation: There must be a direct causal link between the damage and the act or action of the administration.
- Time limit: In a full remedy action based on an act, 60 days from notification of the act; in an action based on an action, an application must be made to the administration within 1 year of learning of the event causing the damage and in any event within 5 years (İYUK Art. 13).
The Process in Administrative Cases
The stages we follow in administrative court cases at Şahin Hukuk Bürosu:
- Review of the Act and Documents Careful review of the notification of the administrative act, its reasoning, the underlying legislation and the procedures followed.
- Checking Time Limits Establishing the 60-day (or other statutory) preclusive time limit for filing.
- Drafting the Petition and Filing the Case Substantiating the grounds for annulment, setting out the unlawfulness with legal reasoning and drafting the statement of claim.
- Request for Stay of Execution Requesting a stay of execution under İYUK Art. 27 where there is manifest unlawfulness and a risk of irreparable harm.
- Written Proceedings and Replies Replying to the administration's defence, challenging expert reports, and submitting additional statements and documents.
- Judgment and Legal Remedies Monitoring implementation by the administration if the judgment is favourable; appeal and cassation if it is not, and, where necessary, an individual application to the Constitutional Court.
Our Approach
Administrative law requires attention to short time limits and technical knowledge of legislation. At Şahin Hukuk Bürosu we offer:
- Monitoring the 60-day time limit: As the preclusive time limit is critical in administrative proceedings, we assess notifications immediately and start case preparation without delay.
- Administrative remedies: Using the required administrative applications and objections before litigation.
- Stay of execution: Effective use of requests for a stay of execution to prevent irreparable harm.
- Monitoring legislation: Closely following current regulations given that administrative legislation changes frequently.
- Constitutional Court route: Where ordinary remedies are exhausted, assessing the possibility of an individual application for alleged violations of fundamental rights.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I challenge an administrative fine?
Administrative fines are challenged before different authorities depending on the type of fine. For fines based on the Misdemeanours Law No. 5326 (such as traffic and environmental fines), the challenge is filed with the criminal judgeship of peace within 15 days of notification. For administrative fines provided for in special laws (such as tax penalties, zoning fines, and banking and capital markets fines), the challenge is filed with the administrative court within 60 days. The petition should state specifically why the fine is unlawful (competence, form, cause, subject matter, purpose). If the deadline is missed, the fine becomes final and moves to collection.
I have been dismissed from the civil service. What remedies do I have?
Against disciplinary penalties imposed under the Civil Servants Law No. 657 (warning, reprimand, salary deduction, suspension of grade progression, dismissal from the civil service), there is first a right of objection to the institution. If the objection is rejected or left unanswered, an annulment action can be filed with the administrative court within 60 days of notification of the act. The case considers arguments such as the disciplinary offence not having occurred or not having been proven, lack of proportionality between the penalty and the act, restriction of the right of defence and failure to follow investigation procedures. If the judgment is favourable, reinstatement, payment of lost salary and recognition of the period as actual service may be claimed.
The municipality has ordered the demolition of my house. What can I do?
As the municipality's demolition order (usually issued under Art. 32 of the Zoning Law No. 3194 or Law No. 6306) is an administrative act, an annulment action can be filed with the administrative court within 60 days of its notification. Because this period is very short and actual demolition is hard to reverse, a request for a stay of execution must always be filed together with the action (İYUK Art. 27). Factors improving the chances of success include compliance with zoning legislation, an application for a building registration certificate, any connection with urban transformation and whether the alleged lack of a permit is accurate. The technical condition of the building may also require an expert examination.
The expropriation compensation offered is too low. What can I do?
Under the Expropriation Law No. 2942, the amount determined when your property is expropriated can be challenged. A compensation determination action is heard by the civil court of first instance where the property is located. Through a panel of experts, the court determines the actual value of the property, taking into account its market value, comparable sales, zoning status and building features. Earlier valuations can be revised, and values significantly higher than the initial offer often result. Where there is de facto seizure without expropriation (the administration taking possession without expropriating), both an end to the seizure and compensation can be claimed.
Can I challenge a tender I did not win?
In tenders under the Public Procurement Law No. 4734, bidders or potential bidders have various rights to challenge acts during the tender process. First, a complaint to the contracting authority is made; against the authority's decision, an objection to the Public Procurement Authority (KİK) is filed. An annulment action can then be filed with the administrative court against the KİK decision. The time limits are very short, and separate time limits apply to each stage of the tender (complaints regarding the tender notice, the specifications, the award decision, etc.). Grounds for complaint may include specifications that restrict competition, acts contrary to the legislation during the tender process or the winner not meeting the qualification criteria.